After winning a qualifying round of surfing for a championship competition, tizzy, optimistic Bethany Hamilton (AnnaSophia Robb) learns a valuable lesson of perspective at Sunday school from the perpetually grinning Carrie Underwood. "If something just isn't adding up, then you need to look at it a different way," she states, without acknowledging the irony of a Christian making such a remark, leading Bethany to cock her head to the side, smile and absorb this pearl of wisdom ― or did she? Foregoing a charity (propaganda) trip to Mexico to help starving kids, or something, she struggles with her decision to serve herself by practicing surfing moves instead of helping others. Of course, a shark bites off her arm, seemingly because God thought that was a kick-ass way to teach her about ― you guessed it ― perspective. In case anyone is confused about where such a peppy, sanitized, but ultimately harmless and fair enough film about supposed Christian values can go from here, Bethany eventually says to a reporter, when asked if she would give up her experience to regain her arm, "I can embrace more people now with one arm than I ever could with two." I'm not going to lie; I laughed my ass off when she said that. But the intended middle-America teen girl audience will most likely find security in her sense of self-confidence and ease, having overcome such an obstacle. Of course, aside from a couple of minor outbursts and a scene of frustrated sandwich making, we never get much of a sense of just how cumbersome living with one arm might be. But, again, this is a very bright and upbeat movie about a girl learning to make the most of a crappy situation. And in that sense, it's actually quite moving and sincere regardless of how unbelievably cornball and unintentionally campy it is. The Blu-Ray supplements are quite comprehensive, including a half-hour documentary about the actual Bethany Hamilton, along with some brief interviews with her on surfing. The "Making of" also has Dennis Quaid finding a polite way to say, "I signed onto the project without reading the script." Judging by his filmography of late, I'm guessing this isn't the first time he's done that.
(Sony)Soul Surfer [Blu-Ray]
Sean McNamara
BY Robert BellPublished Aug 10, 2011