Geordie Greep Says black midi "Hadn’t Really Been on Speaking Terms” Before Breakup

"You ​do ​a ​band ​for ​a ​little ​bit, ​do ​it ​for ​three ​years, ​have ​a ​great ​vibe, ​and ​then ​finish"

Photo: Yis Kid

BY Kaelen BellPublished Sep 4, 2024

Geordie Greep announced his debut solo album The New Sound (and shared its haywire lead single) last month, amidst an avalanche of speculation as to whether black midi were done. It turns out they were, with Greep calling the trio "indefinitely over."

That news was apparently a surprise to bassist Cameron Picton, who wrote on Twitter, "We'd agreed not to say anything about 'breaking up' so I was as blindsided as everyone else last night but maybe in a different way. I guess sometimes all you can say is lol." 

At the same time, the band's management told The Quietus, "After a successful tour including South American dates, they agreed to have a break and do some solo work, with the understanding the black midi door [would] be left open."

Now, Greep has opened up a bit more about the dissolution of his former band. Speaking to NME, he explained that The New Sound marks "the ​first ​time ​that ​I ​was ​very ​transparent ​about ​the ​kind ​of ​music ​I ​like ​to listen ​to." 

He continued: "​I ​loved ​being ​in ​black midi, but these ​are ​songs ​that ​lend ​themselves ​to ​playing ​with ​different ​people. ​Also, ​I ​wanted ​to ​start ​doing ​something ​which ​was ​more ​under ​my ​own ​name ​and ​try ​something ​more ​versatile. ​I ​knew ​I ​wanted ​to do it ​eventually."

Later in the interview, Greep acknowledges that the band had agreed not to mention a breakup, but that he felt like honesty was the best policy. 

If ​I ​was ​to ​do ​it ​again, I ​probably ​would ​have ​done ​it ​differently. But ​in ​the ​moment, ​it ​felt ​very ​important ​to ​me ​that it should be said. We ​hadn't ​really ​been ​on ​speaking ​terms as a band a while before ​that, it had broken ​down in ​communication. When ​we ​first ​decided ​we're ​not ​going ​to ​do ​[black midi] ​anymore, ​we ​had ​said, ​"Let's ​not ​say ​anything ​because ​everyone ​will ​just ​forget." In ​a ​few ​months ​it'll ​be ​obvious, ​and ​we ​won't ​need ​to ​say ​anything ​about ​it. ​But ​then ​it ​became ​apparent ​that ​wasn't ​really ​the ​case. People ​were ​all ​the ​time ​saying, ​"What's ​happening?" ​I ​thought… who ​cares? Let's ​just ​say ​it. It's ​over – I ​don't ​want ​to ​string ​anyone ​along.

Greep says that black midi's demise is "a sad thing," but he seems to be positive about the future of his solo endeavour, saying, "You ​do ​a ​band ​for ​a ​little ​bit, ​do ​it ​for ​three ​years, ​have ​a ​great ​vibe, ​and ​then ​finish. Nothing's ​meant ​to ​go ​on ​forever ​and ​ever." 

Revisit "Holy, Holy" below. 

Tour Dates

Latest Coverage