You Kill Me

John Dahl

BY Paul DuderPublished Oct 26, 2007

It’s winter, there’s polka music on the wireless and you’re out of pirogues, oh, and you’re in Buffalo. So who, I ask you, wouldn’t hit the vodka? But for Frank Falenczyk, button man for the Polish mob, a certain punctiliousness is mandatory and after sleeping through one too many hits, Frank is shipped off to San Francisco to dry out. As played by a goateed and black-liveried Sir Ben Kingsley — extra-taciturn to better swallow his insecurities and wobbly Buffalo accent — Frank shuttles between AA meetings and a make work job at (ooh, irony) a mortuary in search of his absentee mojo. Though he seems as open and pliable as a fist, sobriety comes easily to Frank and the sanctity of his much-used AA confessional is never in doubt, so the dramatic stakes never come to a boil. The group, like love interest Lauren (Téa Leoni), who Frank meets over her uncle’s corpse, is bought off by Frank’s "everyone I killed knew it was a possibility” mentality, so icky moral qualms are likewise happily dispensed with. Leoni’s Hepburn-esque, good-at-games coltishness works well here but the total lack of back-story leaves us a little baffled as to why she’s so unperturbed by the age difference and his line of work. Meanwhile, back in Buffalo, which, like San Francisco, is well-rendered by Winnipeg, Frank’s Polish confreres are in a turf war with the Irish mob (led by Dennis Farina, busting out from the Italian mobster casting ghetto), wherein — as with academic politics — things get so nasty because the stakes (snowploughing routes) are so small. Director Dahl, continuing to follow up Red Rock West and The Last Seduction with a slow descent into milquetoast-ery, has trouble mediating between the black and the comedy. Grosse Pointe Blank, the obvious referent, had a subtler tone and a longer, less predictable arc; here, our takeaway is pretty much only some tepid 12-step-isms and a yawn-inducing paean to the redemptive power of a good woman. The extras, similarly, are thin. There are a (by-now pro forma) "behind the scenes” thingy — stop the presses: everybody loved everybody — and a commentary track with Dahl and the screenwriters, who seem more geeked to talk about themselves and their "craft” than to impart any great insight.
(Hidden Agenda)

Latest Coverage