Rough Trades current swelling roster of talent each select a Rough Trade track from the past 25 years to cover. The results are impressive in showcasing the quality, depth and eclectic nature of Rough Trades history. The only point of contention is that recent Rough Trade discoveries-turned-stadium fillers, the Strokes, get selected not once but twice to be covered whereas every other original selection is between ten and 20 years old. If were going to point fingers, Canadas very own Royal City along with the Detroit Cobras are the ones to blame for picking songs from the Stokes debut to pay homage to. The rest of this collection, however, displays Rough Trades brilliant past and almost every track is a keeper. Where Adam Green and Belle & Sebastian do a couple of Young Marble Giants songs, the Tyde and British Sea Power tackle the warm fuzz of Galaxie 500. The Fall are finely represented by Fiery Furnaces, oddball Jeffrey Lewis suitably takes on Television Personalities, the Cocteau Twins Elizabeth Fraser is stunning on her Robert Wyatt cover and Aztec Cameras are rendered in their pure pop beauty by Mystic Chords of Memory. Personal faves include the great Scritti Politti track "Lions After Slumber taken on by the Veils, Oneidas tightly wound performance of James "Blood Ulmers "Jazz Is The Teacher, Funk Is The Preacher, the homage to American indie rock icons the Feelies by Eastern Lane and Torontos Hidden Cameras outdoing New Zealands indie pop originators the Clean.
(Rough Trade)Various
Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before
BY Ian DanzigPublished Jan 1, 2006