After a handful of releases for Fat Wreck Chords and Kung Fu Records, the Ataris first major-label release shows the bands pop punk sound reaching an increased level of refinement, enhanced by the watertight production of Lou Giordano. Despite the sonic strengths of the disc, the Ataris lyrics occasionally resemble gawky high school yearbook poetry with lines such as, "If I died tomorrow, would this song live on forever? from "Unopened Letter to the World, an awkward nod to Emily Dickinson. The bands straight-faced, fist-pumping rendition of Don Henleys "The Boys of Summer also wallows in too much backwards-looking 80s nostalgia. Despite So Long, Astorias faltering moments, MTV and Warped Tour fans are bound to eat it up like caviar.
(Columbia)Ataris
So Long, Astoria
BY Rob NayPublished Aug 1, 2003