The Illusionist Neil Burger
Published Sep 01, 2006Playing a master of slight of hand, disappearances and other tricks of the 19th century illusionists trade, Edward Norton manages to distract us only briefly before we realise that theres not much behind this tale of supernatural romance.
Norton is Eisenheim the Illusionist, delighting Viennese crowds with instantly growing fruit trees; as his reputation rises, he gains the attention of Crown Prince Leopold (Dark Citys Rufus Sewell), as well as the citys Chief Inspector Uhl (Paul Giamatti). While Uhl is an eager, curious observer and fancies himself a bit of an amateur conjurist as well the attention Eisenheim draws from Prince Leopolds fiancé Sophie (Jessica Biel) angers the man who would be Emperor.
Neil Burger, adapting the film from a short story by Steven Millhauser, sets up the atmosphere reasonably but does little to let us into Eisenheims world. Only at plot convenient points do we realise that Sophie and the magician shared a brief but life defining childhood moment, and from the second she steps on stage to participate in one of his tricks, their life paths inevitably follow down the road of tragic movie romances between power and poverty. With Inspector Uhl charged with proving Eisenheim a fraud and Prince Leopold growing ever angrier at the magicians fame and influence, Eisenheim embarks upon a most spectacular show, engineering an escape not just from stage but from Vienna and Leopolds clutches.
The Illusionist plays both sides on the magic front at times, Eisenheim is simply a talented master, at other times hes connected in deeper ways to the spirit world but ultimately, the story itself is thin and the talented cast is given too little to work with, particularly Norton. The films various tricks are distracting for a while but it lacks a finale that satisfies its ambitions. (Alliance Atlantis)