Nerdy debates aside about whether the world needs another collection of Zep tunes (the answer is probably no, but we do like different track orders and cover art), its hard to not be blown away by Mothership. A double CD collection taking a chronological walk through the bands eight studio albums, it has some of the songs youd expect ("Stairway to Heaven) and a few odd omissions ("The Battle of Evermore), but you cant win them all. The liner notes by rock journalist David Fricke are a good read, the art and packaging is nice, but the main attraction is the remastered (again?) sound, bringing out the splendid bass playing of John Paul Jones and the drumming of John Bonham in all its unhinged glory. And lets face it: these songs are only getting better with time. The Song Remains the Same is a double CD reissue of the bands 1976 live album, notable for a few reasons. One, liner notes from Cameron Crowe are wrapped up in the nice packaging. Two, this is remastered as well, but although it sounds pristine, that doesnt take away from the albums faults. Three, and most excitingly for Zep-heads, is the inclusion of no less than six tracks not on the original release. Of those, "Black Dog is cool for its "Bring it on Home intro and the explosive "Since Ive Been Loving You is a highlight, almost good enough to make the listener ignore the sloppiness and rambling nature of the bulk of the tracks (disc two is a write-off). All told, a couple more entries to the canon of one of rocks best: a band that managed to sing about Gollum and sound awesome at the same time, and a band that did enough good that we can forgive the exhausting 29-minute live jams.
(Swan Song/Atlantic)Led Zeppelin
Mothership/The Song Remains the Same
BY Greg PrattPublished Nov 29, 2007