If reviews of Celebrations 2005 self-titled debut are anything to go by, its easy to fold our arms and peg them as TV On The Radio wannabes. By and large these comparisons were generally warranted, as David Sitek produced it, with other TVOTR members in tow. This sophomore record is similarly inclined: Siteks back tweaking knobs as producer and Tumbe and co. lend their voices on a couple of tracks. But with the prog-y post-punk of The Modern Tribe, Celebration well and truly step out of the shadow of their Brooklyn buddies with some help from their friends (Nick Zinner, Antibalas). Drummer David Bergander is a force, shifting from low-key syncopations to unhinged cacophony as the song dictates the Antibalas collaboration ("Hands Off My Gold) in particular is a thing of sublime polyrhythmic beauty. But the real star is Katrina Fords versatile, jaw-dropping voice it coos, wails and occasionally unfurls into an impossibly huge, soulful croon. The TVOTR comparisons wont stop anytime soon but Celebration can rest assured theyve set themselves apart with this sumptuous effort.
(4AD)Celebration
The Modern Tribe
BY Pras RajagopalanPublished Oct 9, 2007