Most tribute albums suck, so let's cut to the few redeeming qualities of this one, focused on pre-Swordfishtrombones-era Waits. Neko Case tackles "Christmas Card From a Hooker in Minneapolis" with gorgeous grace and empathy, showing that she could have a torchy jazz career if for some obtuse reason her many other talents don't pan out. Lydia Lunch delivers a version of "Heartattack and Vine" that's much too faithful, right down to the stuttering vocal, although Nels Cline's guitar work is searing. Chicago's the Blacks do a great gender-fucked version of "Goin' Out West" live, but here they do alright with "Poncho's Lament." Everyone else can go home. The old paint job looked fine.
(Manifesto)Various
New Coat of Paint: Songs of Tom Waits
BY Michael BarclayPublished Jun 1, 2000