If youre going to go retro, this is how its done. Stoltz isnt coy about his 60s forbearers; instead he aims for the heart of the three-minute miracle that is a pop song. While he doesnt shun the Beatless touchstones, he spends more time working the margins of playbooks from Love, the Zombies and the Box Tops for his pop hooks. On tracks like "To Speak to the Girl (running time: three minutes), he nails everything the upswept bass hook, seesaw rhythm guitar, background handclaps, the acoustic 12-string bridge and harmonica extro. He even wedges in arty bits like the Velvets "ching, ching, ching and Bowies saxophones on "The Birmingham Eccentric. And there isnt a dud amongst the other 12 tracks. The fact that Stoltz, with a little detail help from friends, records everything himself makes it all the more impressive. His previous Sub Pop release (this is his fourth full-length overall), Under the Branches, got praised but mostly disappeared from the public radar. Lets hope that quality trumps buzz this time around.
(Sub Pop)Kelley Stoltz
Circular Songs
BY Eric HillPublished Feb 5, 2008