Dirty Children lead singer Nadia Fay sounds a lot like Yeah Yeah Yeahs Karen O. From the frequent yelps to the same breathy grunts and lyrical enunciation, its almost impossible to not hear the similarities between the two. Even their slower material owes the same kind of debt, if purely by similarities in vocal performance, to the Pretenders. But Yeah Yeah Yeahs fanatics hold up; the voice may be uncanny, but Fays lyrics wallow in poor-me/religion sucks pseudo "dark grade school poetry, rarely giving the music a chance. And what about that music? Its more fleshed out than their NY counterparts to be sure but without the dynamic energy, memorable riffs or emotional heft. Shut Off the World is a confident record, one from a band who clearly know what kind of music they want to make; its just too bad that so much of it is riddled with incredibly poor lyrics and "sounds like comparisons to artists whove been there before, and whove done it better.
(Independent)Dirty Children
Shut Off the World
BY Scott ReidPublished Sep 1, 2005