No surprises here! This is Julian Kosters singing saw, carolling Christmas tunes and thats it. The singing saw isnt about to replace Bing Crosby at family gatherings but saw aficionados (and there are a few, from Marlene Dietrich to the Black Heart Procession) and fans of offbeat instruments couldnt ask for a more charming stocking stuffer. Though the saw might seem more like a Halloween sound effect to most, its well-suited to Christmas you use one to cut logs, as the liner notes point out, and to the refined ear it has a warm, old-timey sound. Koster, a saw virtuoso, has great pitch (which is difficult to conjure, believe me), and a lot of conviction if anyone could convince the layman that the saw is a legitimate instrument and not just a novelty, its the man from the Music Tapes. The same goes for this record. Its not for everyone, and those who buy it arent likely to add it to their iPods, but its an awfully cute project from someone with a genuine love for the sonority of the serrated instrument.
(Merge Records)Julian Koster
The Singing Saw at Christmastime
BY Alex MolotkowPublished Oct 25, 2008