Barton Carroll The Lost One
Published Jan 28, 2008
Northwestern songsmith Carroll has toured and recorded with Crooked Fingers and Eric Bachmann, but this, his third album, establishes him as a serious solo contender. A wistful and melancholy tone infuses his vocals, as on haunting steel-tinged opener "Pretty Girls Going To Ruin My Life (Again). The often sardonic, lustful and self-deprecating lyrics keep him from being pegged as just another sad sack, angst-filled artiste, however. Hes most ambitious, musically and lyrically, on "Small Thing, a six-minute epic featuring brass and strings that references Stalingrad and the ravages of war. Josh Ritter would gladly claim this one. Far lighter is one of the albums most melodic cuts, "Brooklyn Girl, Youre Going To Be My Bride. Admitting, "Im not a dandy or the sharpest knife in the drawer, he seeks to woo a girl whos "drowning in boys and hipster noise. The slow "Burning Red And Blue is both sinister and erotic, with Carroll pleading for a lover to "wear something lacy and black to give me my fun. Theres not a dud here, the musicianship is top-notch and theres enough stylistic variety to keep things interesting. Why an album this good, and recorded two years ago, is just now being released is unclear, but we can be grateful it didnt end up as a lost one.
(Skybucket)