Despite her obvious talents, when an Aimee Mann album falls into your lap, you know the product very well. Tales of turmoil and wry observation layered around a strong rock background and Manns formidable, distinctive voice. Its a formula thats worked admirably well since Bachelor No. 2, and this new concept album is not going to rock anyones boat. From the driving beat and rock licks of opener "Dear John, to the piano-driven "I Cant Help You Anymore, Mann crafts her songs and delivery to give the goods that her fans are used to. Befitting her boxer-themed tales, this album is actually a much more muscular affair, particularly "Clean Up for Christmas, which is one of the noisiest songs Manns graced us with. Vocally, Mann has never been better, with her husky, yet smooth alto the strongest its ever been; ample evidence is found in the befittingly wrenching "Thats How I Knew This Story Would Break My Heart. If the album suffers from anything its Manns refusal to take any big leaps with her sound or delivery. Now, theres no need for a leap into prog-rock, but something different may help stem the tide and stop any other strong work being forgotten like this albums titular arm.
(SuperEgo)Aimee Mann
The Forgotten Arm
BY Chris WhibbsPublished May 1, 2005