Five long years later, Newsom has returned with fourth album Divers, a shorter but no less imaginative LP that finds the singer returning to the conventional track runtimes of her debut, The Milk-Eyed Mender, but unfettered by the cutesy, freak-folk connotations that unfairly dogged that album.
For the most part, that means more of the striking melodies and tortuous chord progressions she's long been known for, arranged more inventively than ever before: "Leaving the City" begins with staccato harp plucking, but it's accentuated with scratching, distorted organ and a thumping kick-snare combo that drives the spiralling chorus; a sombre accordion converses with a fiddle and piccolo on "Waltz of the 101st Lightborne"; subtle patches of wheezing, scratchy organ add whimsy to the towering "You Will Not Take My Heart Alive," the chorus of which finds Newsom scaling previously unknown heights with her multi-faceted, idiosyncratic voice — which is better than ever on this album — as she promises, "I won't come 'round this way again, where the lonely wind abides / and you will not take my heart alive."
If there's a common lyrical theme here, it's difficult to discern — Newsom touches on death, love and, on the dynamic, piano-driven march "Sapokanikan," the passage of time — making Divers feel more like a collection of short stories than a novel. The cumulative effect is nonetheless dazzling, especially on the title track centrepiece, a seven-minute ode to the isolating, disorienting nature of lost love constructed around a pretty, lilting harp melody that builds but, pointedly, never quite reaches a climax.
Still, it's just one highlight on a record full of them. Rather than breaking from Newsom's tradition of complex, bewitching songwriting, Divers feels like the culmination of all of Newsom's incredible work over the past decade. It's the sound of an artist operating at the peak of her powers, employing all her greatest strengths at once to create an assured, moving work that corroborates what Have One On Me already suggested: that Joanna Newsom is one of the finest songwriters of this generation. (Drag City)