What makes this album worthwhile to the already devoted Bloodshot fan is how well the songs stand up when reimagined. Robbie Fulks' songs, for example, comes across sad and sweet without his characteristic sneer attached; Neko Case's writing shines even when sung by a voice other than her own dazzling one; and Ryan Adams, one of the most covered artists on this compilation, sounds just fine when stripped of his bombastic rock star ambitions (although Superchunk's raucous pop-punk sing-along cover of "Come Pick me Up" arguably improves upon the new-Dylan dirge of the original).
If you're new to the label, or the genre, While No One Was Looking gives you twice the bang for your buck; it'll make you want to hear more from both the original artists and those playing the covers. The compilation serves its purpose perfectly: not only does it make you want to listen to it over again, but you'll also end up with a long list of albums to (re)discover. (Bloodshot)