They "started a new wave revival and finger-pointed to "copyists, issued death threats to emo bands, and most recently declared their sophomore album the best album of the last two decades without any kind of backlash; in many ways the Killers are fucking untouchable. Whats most surprising, though, is how a great band can do whatever they want without actually releasing a strong album. Hot Fuss, their debut, may have seduced 4 million customers, but the cold hard truth is it was a flawed album carried by strong singles. Funny enough, Sams Town is basically the same picture: strong anthems lost in a sea of superficial filler but without that flashy pink leather blazer. Instead, the Killers have traded in their glam and Duran Duran fixation for some four-day stubble and a Springsteen box set; its painfully obvious they felt the 80s bandwagon was headed for a cliff and reinvention was mandatory. Ace single "When You Were Young is simply "Mr. Brightside aping "Born to Run, while "The River Is Wild tries to build a story Boss-style using rugged enunciation and lines like, "This town was meant for passing through/But it aint nothing new. Its blatant, but then so is the Brandon Flowers Meatloaf obsession, which explodes when the drama becomes too much. Their best the warm synthetic "Read My Mind and the uplifting but poorly named "Bling (Confessions of a King) meets their worst the lyrically dreadful "Uncle Johnny and the goofy Queen-isms of "Bones, and its a constant battle that never ends with satisfaction. Essentially, this is sure to keep their popularity, but if theyre hoping for the legacy they feel they deserve its going to take a lot more work and a lot less talk.
(Island Records)The Killers
Sam's Town
BY Cam LindsayPublished Nov 1, 2006