I somehow doubt that Ben Afflecks melancholy directorial debut will change his flagging fortunes, but its not for lack of ability. Although crime-genre trappings hamper his films ability to make a point, a deeply felt sense of frustration and disappointment overwhelm its many flaws.
Set in working-class Boston, it posits Casey Affleck as a private detective called in to help with an abducted-child case thats shattered his neighbourhood. He quickly uncovers that the devastated mother was in fact getting high when her daughter got snatched, but thats only the beginning of a case that leads to drug dealers, child molesters, corrupt cops and a wealth of complexity that Affleck can barely deal with.
The movie often cant deal with it either, largely due to the "complete the task mentality that shoehorns subtext into a format that isnt necessarily expressive. But both the material (from a Dennis Lehane novel) and the follow-through offer views of seedy urban life (and the despair that lives there) that are pretty hard to find elsewhere in current American film.
Though Michelle Monaghan is too glamorous as the younger Afflecks wife and partner, the rest of the supporting cast seem infinitely credible as people who live outside of the economic centre of power, and they powerfully radiate their dissatisfaction. Further, once the films moral crisis becomes apparent (and props to Ben Affleck for concealing it so long), its an interesting conundrum rather than a springboard to self-righteous grandstanding.
Clint Eastwood made a more polished Lehane adaptation with Mystic River but this movie is rawer, less polite and committed to a sense of helplessness that Eastwood could never achieve. The directorial hand is a tad unsure but its instincts are sharp and they carry you through to the end. (Warner)