Iíve tried to follow pretty closely everything youíve done in the last few years, putting out three records and producing some for other artists, so first I wanted to ask if it was as much of a whirlwind for you as it seemed?
Hmm, probably not. It probably wasnít as intense as it should seem to me, mainly because it was fun for the most part. The making of this stuff was really fun, and it didnít really seem like it was going that fast, just because the material was there. But I noticed that everyone around me was up for the challenge of getting it done, and knew that it was going to be really hard. And at that time I wasnít necessarily into doing a lot of press for anything because I knew the work schedule itself was going to be really intense. I thought that it was going to go really quick, and in retrospect I donít think it strained me in some kind of unreasonable way. The only negative projection that I can think of now is that the songs were happening so fast that if they had not gone down and been released, then we would have lost some great tunes. Most of them were really great live, and in fact Iím just starting to find my footing with some of them. The Cardinals and I are just musically falling in love with parts of Cold Roses that never got a chance to get played, and "29Ē has become a band favourite to play. If those songs werenít out there, we probably wouldnít be playing them now, and playing them better in some cases. So the process is super-important to serve the songs the best we could at that moment. They had to come out.
On Easy Tiger, the band is still the Cardinals?
It is the Cardinals. Some of the tracks are just me ó not doing everything, but close to doing everything with [guitarist] Neal [Casal] or [pedal steel guitarist] Jon [Graboff] coming in later to fill in the blanks. I kind of looked to them when I started making it, because I wasnít really sure I could make it. I wasnít sure how I was going to do a record more stripped-back, more from my perspective, because theyíre such good friends and good band-mates. I just care to be around them when Iím playing, so I think they gave me a lot of confidence. At some points, a track would come up and Iíd be like, "God, Iíve gotta cut this track but I donít want to play all the parts,Ē so they were just there for me. Itís a weird example, but I like to think of it like how it was with the Grateful Dead when Bob or Jerry wanted to do solo records and they would end up calling the rest of the guys to play on them. For me, I just have a comfortability with those guys. The funny thing was, I wasnít confident about many of those tunes because they were just so me, you know? The way I found a way to live in them was by asking those guys, which ones do you want me to pursue, or which ones do you think are worthy? Those guys would always pick the hard ones. Theyíd say, like, look man, this is a good tune. I know itís kind of heavy and you might not want to go digging through all that emotional information, but that ended up making it fun for me by giving me a different perspective through the arrangements. Nealís very pushy when it comes to that. Whenever Iíd be like, ĎAh, this song sucks,í heíd say, ĎCome on, letís just play it a couple times and by then you wonít be thinking about it.í Heís usually right. I typically like the songs that are more riffage, or have a more general overview. So Iím so glad that they were there in that way. If I had done it myself with just acoustic guitar or piano, it would have been such a different record with such a different approach.
Yeah, my initial reaction was how concise the record is. It made me think that it might shut up some of your critics who think that you donít know how to edit yourself.
But what are they really talking about when they say that? I know what you mean, and Iíve wrestled with that when I think about what some critics have said about me. But then I think, well, theyíre not a gang, theyíre individual people, although sometimes they seem to get a vibe about what something is by looking at what other critics have said or written. The idea that Iím prolific ó I just see that word and hear it in questions all the time. Itís one of those things thatís been passed from journalist to journalist. Itís a fail-safe thing to ask me about, whereas my opinion is that the work speaks for itself. It isnít really about whether Iím prolific, itís just the output that I have. In my mind I always think, Iím prolific compared to what? Is it the modern idea of what a consistent musical flow would be for a person? I guess for me, music is so often not dangerous, or not bothersome, that I donít understand the negative connotation.
Right. I guess itís just that so many artists today arenít allowed to develop naturally and explore so many different areas like youíve done.
Right. But some of that was work, though. I think, if anything, some of it was because I just pressed forward so hard, thinking to myself that the work was going to speak for itself, not me. And I see that a lot. I see people who should probably make five records in the time it takes to make one. Maybe five years later someone like that will realize thereís so much to learn from what they used to think was a mistake in composition. When I go to museums, I like to look at an artistís work as an overview of, say, a ten-year period. Sometimes the missteps always seem to precede an epiphany, and I really like that. I really like peaks and valleys. Thereís a lot of beauty and subtlety when composition breaks down in order to find a new way. Stories need their very calm and seemingly useless passages in order to make the next event more than it is, like in a movie when thereís a lull. That makes the next huge event as it should be. I guess I follow that kind of thinking, and I think music can handle it.
That begs the question of what epiphany you had with this record, and to me the obvious hint is the last track, "Taught Myself How To Grow Old.Ē
I think thatís the heaviest one. I think thatís the one I was waiting for. That happened in, like, five fucking minutes too. I did that and two other tracks that are b-sides in one afternoon in the studio that Iím at right now. [Producer] Jamie [Candiloro] was mixing some stuff and I said I had a couple of ideas. We waited a few days, because I was feeling a little too emotionally intense to try to level out one song after the next the way I normally do. So I took a break ó I only live a few blocks from the studio ó and I ended up finishing the words for "Taught MyselfĒ right before I cut it. Then I didnít listen to it for a week. I know why, because I never would have been able to sit down and work on something like that, which is kind of brutal. [Pause] But sonically, Jamie has a style thatís all about clarity. We donít hide anything with him.
Yeah, I was going to say that the albumís got such a cool, mid-í70s glow to it. To me, it doesnít really sound like your other records.
Yeah, and Jamieís in the Cards now. Heís playing piano and other stuff, while working on the box set. Heís a true bro to everyone in the band, so he just integrated so perfectly. When I produce, I like a lot of depth and mystery, and have things be a bit obscured or sound nasty and ratty. I used to think that HŁsker DŁ records sounded like that because it was a style they were going for, but Jamieís opinion is it was as good as they could make it ó they were in a garage. Iím like, no they did all this on purpose, so thatís the approach Iíve taken on some of the stuff Iíve produced. But for Jamie itís all about less interference. And itís fucking tough, because when weíre trying to cut a track and itís not working, I used to think it was the sonics, but for him, the truth is right there in front of you. If itís not speaking, it doesnít mean that Iím crap or the songís crap necessarily, it just means that the song doesnít communicate as well as others. Thatís terrifying for me who writes tons of shit. Itís a cool challenge though.
What was it like producing Willie Nelson then?
I learned a lot of life lessons mostly. I mean, he works very quickly and it was very spare. We didnít see him a lot, because the sessions were over a couple of different months. And also when it came up that it was something we were going to do, I was adamant that if the Cards were going to back him up, I would have to produce so we wouldnít have to worry about someone interfering with our sound. So they agreed to let it go down the way it went down in the studio, and I put some limits on what was going to happen in order to keep the integrity of the recording. It reminded me kind of how Jack and Meg White work, the way that their limits make them seem stronger and more able to be resourceful and economical. In thinking about that, I wanted everyone to set up in the room around Willie, with only [drummer] Brad [Pemberton] wearing headphones, and everyone using ratty old amps so that the main thing everyone heard was Willieís voice and guitar. It was cool because it made everyone listen really hard, and I think it enabled Willie to throw the band a little more, and suck them in. It turned into a real healthy struggle. But other than that we didnít see a lot of him because I think he was pressed for time, and maybe recording in New York was a little overwhelming for him. It was just a different process. I think heís used to coming in with the track already done and just singing over it.
You mentioned a box set. Is that on tap next?
I think so. Iíve been mostly working on artwork for it, Jamieís been putting it together, which is great. Thereís been so many records that were lost in the shuffle in between the records that came out, it really was funny that thereís never been a lapse in working. In between Heartbreaker and Gold, and Gold and the subsequent records, even in the last few years thereís been completed records, some that leaked to the Internet but not in their finished form, and some that no oneís ever heard. It seemed like a good idea to put it all together into one insane, awesome box set that people could go to if they wanted. I asked Jamie to help with it because some of the audio is damaged, and some of it had never been mixed. Like, thereís a record called 48 Hours that Ethan [Johns] did that people have had for many years because of the Internet, but with a lot of tracks missing. So thereís things like that, as well as things like the record I wrote right after Heartbreaker called Suicide Handbook, which would have been Gold. Whatever people have heard of that never got mixed and doesnít have the strings and other tracks I put on it. Hearing all that stuff again has been kind of mind-blowing, and Jamieís been great in putting it all together. But for the time being, the band and I just want to go out and tour Easy Tiger, and for the first time Iím really feeling like I want to open up and talk about the process.
FeaturesFeb 17, 2015
When Luke Doucet and Melissa McClelland first joined forces as Whitehorse in 2011, their assorted sound was still finding its roots in a mel...
FeaturesFeb 10, 2015
Father John MistyLove is a Drug
Sometimes it's hard to figure out where Father John Misty ends and Josh Tillman begins. From his early days as a singer-songwriter peddling ...
NewsFeb 09, 2015
Whitehorse Share Lessons Learned on 'Leave No Bridge Unburned'
When Luke Doucet and Melissa McClelland first formed Whitehorse in 2011, they were very adamant on remaining a duo both in the studio and on...
FeaturesFeb 04, 2015
Dan ManganNo More Mr. Nice Guy (Oh Who Are We Kidding?)
"Part of the 'Dan Mangan' thing is being this super, super nice guy," reflects the man in question. "It's not that I'm no longer nice, but I...