News

PNR Rockfest 2013

Recently Reviewed

CC XX Grizzly Bear

Pop & Rock 2011: 30 Best Albums

Page 29

Features > Year In Review > Dec 2011

Pop & Rock 2011: 30 Best Albums - Page 29
29. Wilco The Whole Love (dbpm)
Even as The Whole Love lands as another stunning example of Wilco's significance in contemporary pop music, it also serves as the culmination of a ten-year arc that has invariably been coupled with the notion of "challenging" one thing or another. The band's 21st century was marred/heightened early on by a David-vs-Goliath battle with Warner about Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, which the label saw no commercial potential for, even as the record grew into one of the most accomplished, inventive, and emulated albums in rock. Wilco won that public battle even as some in their fan base grumbled about their newest songs, which tended more towards lyrical abstraction, squalls of noise, and virtuoso, prog-y musicianship, as opposed to the "alt-country" scene Jeff Tweedy was spawned from. So, in summary everyone, at some point, seems to believe that Wilco is working against them, even though the band itself is rather populist and giving in nature. Their primary shield against haters has been an unwavering belief in itself and that it's okay to evolve with every passing year ― something that Tweedy in particular has a deep investment in. "I've never been that big of a Paul Simon fan, but there are things about his new record that I've found really inspiring and really hopeful for somebody that's not particularly young anymore, like myself, and somebody still working hard at challenging himself and still giving a shit," Tweedy told Exclaim! in September. "I just wanna see people that still give a shit. To be honest, I wanna see young bands that give a shit! That's the part that's really more disturbing than an older guy not giving a shit any more, but I see a lot of bands and I'm like, 'Really? How am I supposed to care if you don't care,' y'know? I don't get it." Challenge! The words come from a reformed punk rock enthusiast who figured out that you actually should learn how to play your instrument and hone your craft. For his part, Tweedy has many gifts as a songwriter, chief among them is a knack for infectious hooks, verses, choruses, and an ability to infuse sweet sounds with a gritty edge. As such, The Whole Love is the most nuanced Wilco album yet, subtly adopting punk free-form with new wave vigour and the sensitivity of seasoned folk, blending together and coming the closest in line to the daring of the Beatles without shamelessly mimicking them or anyone else.
Vish Khanna



« Page 28 | Page 30 »
GET IT! Mailing List SHARE IT! Google+Google BookmarksEmailStumbleUponRedditTumblrTwitterFacebook
December 02, 2011Nameless Poseur9627
I love that Dog Day made this list, Deformer is one awesome album!
Start Conversation
December 02, 2011Nameless Poseur9635
Good to see Destroyer's masterpiece Kaputt so high on the list!
Start Conversation
December 03, 2011Nameless Poseur9640
But where are Other Lives???????????

http://youtu.be/ngNpXyaZD...
Start Conversation
December 03, 2011Nameless Poseur9645
Too soon this year for year end lists! BLACK KEYS new one is gonna rate right up there.
Start Conversation
December 05, 2011Nameless Poseur9666
Where is Katy Perry? She4's cool isnt she?
Start Conversation
December 05, 2011Nameless Poseur9671
Good list, I'd argue with many, but I think that's part of the fun. And, I agree, Black Keys will likely be close to the top. I just finished my first listen, it's sick. I'd also add Ottawa's The Golden Seals on there. And Gillian Welch, her new one is fantastic.
Start Conversation
December 05, 2011Nameless Poseur9674
No Bjork = bullshit.
Start Conversation
December 05, 2011Nameless Poseur9675
The Bjork was boring and way too safe. Good to leave that one off.
Start Conversation
December 05, 2011Nameless Poseur9684
Dudes, Kurt Vile shoulda been at the top of this shit! And no love for Josh T Pearson and David Lynch? Jeeeeeez
Start Conversation
December 05, 2011Nameless Poseur9685
Gillian Welch is here, on the Folk and Country list:
http://exclaim.ca/Feature...
Start Conversation
December 06, 2011Nameless Poseur9700
no fleet foxes ... what a joke !
Start Conversation
December 06, 2011Nameless Poseur9712
Um, Bon Iver but no Fleet Foxes? You've lost all cred. Ridiculous.
Start Conversation
December 06, 2011Nameless Poseur9717
That Fleet Foxes record SUCKED
Start Conversation
December 06, 2011Nameless Poseur9734
i love jimmy so very much. good one
Start Conversation
December 07, 2011Nameless Poseur9748
WTF is this dog shit? where are the ROCK bands on this list? no doubt this was put together by some asshole with a beard, for assholes with beards. i thought rock albums were supposed to you know, ROCK. this is all stuff i'd want to put on at night to help me fall asleep.
Start Conversation
December 09, 2011Nameless Poseur9816
Wow, I'm actually extremely surprised Chad Vangaalen didn't make the cut...
Start Conversation
December 12, 2011Nameless Poseur9842
Yuck? Yes.
Austra? Terrible choice... for anything... to do with listening to things.
Toronto's scene needs to let go of their ego on that one.
Start Conversation
December 13, 2011Nameless Poseur9895
I agree with the dude above me; Austra sucks. And where's Tomboy?
Start Conversation
December 15, 2011Nameless Poseur9942
1 Colin StetsonNew History Warfare Vol. 2: Judges
2 Oneohtrix Point NeverReplica
3 GirlsFather, Son, Holy Ghost
4 James BlakeJames Blake
5 M83Hurry Up, We're Dreaming
6 Shabazz PalacesBlack Up
7 Fucked UpDavid Comes To Life
8 The FieldLooping State Of Mind
9 Tune-YardsW H O K I L L
10 PJ HarveyLet England Shake
11 Bon IverBon Iver, Bon Iver
12 Panda BearTomboy
13 DestroyerKaputt
14 St. VincentStrange Mercy
15 RadioheadThe King Of Limbs
16 Cass McCombsWIT'S END
17 Atlas SoundParallax
18 Tim HeckerRavedeath, 1972
19 Sandro PerriImpossible Spaces
20 BraidsNative Speaker
21 Gang Gang DanceEye Contact
22 The CaretakerAn Empty Bliss Beyond This World
23 EMAPast Life Martyred Saints
24 Peaking Lights936
25 Bill CallahanApocalypse
26 Ford & LopatinChannel Pressure
27 Mikal CroninMikal Cronin
28 Dirty BeachesBadlands
29 Real EstateDays
30 Smith WesternsDye It Blonde
31 The WeekndHouse of Balloons
32 WU LYFGo Tell Fire To The Mountain
33 Youth LagoonThe Year of Hibernation
34 GrouperA I A
35 The Pains Of Being Pure...Belong
36 PonytailDo Whatever You Want All The Time
37 Fleet FoxesHelplessness Blues
38 Cass McCombsHumor Risk
39 John MausWe Must Become the Pitiless Censors of Ourselves
40 ThundercatThe Golden Age of Apocalypse
41 The Rural Alberta AdvantageDeparting
42 Gil Scott-Heron & Jamie XXWe're New Here
43 BattlesGloss Drop
44 ByetoneSymeta
45 Jürgen MüllerScience Of The Sea
46 FeistMetals
47 Dum Dum GirlsOnly in Dreams
48 DrakeTake Care
49 Kurt VileSmoke Ring for My Halo
50 Nicolas JaarSpace Is Only Noise
Start Conversation
December 15, 2011Nameless Poseur9943
Now THAT'S a list worth sharing.
Start Conversation
December 16, 2011chedderpinks9959
Where the f$%k are Demons Claws & Tandoori Knights?
Start Conversation
December 19, 2011Nameless Poseur9994
bon iver is boring
Start Conversation
December 19, 2011Nameless Poseur9995
I like reading through peoples comments with this guide. http://www.npr.org/blogs/...-20-unhappiest-people-you-meet-in-the-comments-sections-of-year-end-lists?sc=tw&cc=share
Start Conversation
December 20, 2011Nameless Poseur10004
Bon Iver is over rated garbage
Start Conversation
December 24, 2011Nameless Poseur10135
See NPR link two posts back. A must read after reading this list (or any list) comment thread
Start Conversation
December 27, 2011Nameless Poseur10164
No way the Golden Seals record was going to make that list. Exclaim didn't even bother to review it.
Start Conversation
December 27, 2011Nameless Poseur10168
My (humble) best of 2011:
ludditestereo.net
Start Conversation
January 03, 2012Nameless Poseur10230
It's blasphemy that Young Galaxy's Shapeshifting is not on this list.
Start Conversation
January 03, 2012tmakworld10262
Here is a top 10 albums of 2011 list for the classic rock type of music crowd. Thoughts? www.tmakworld.com
Start Conversation
January 04, 2012Nameless Poseur10280
Most of that list represents everything that is WRONG with music lately. SAFE + PREDICTABLE = BOREING.
Start Conversation
January 12, 2012Nameless Poseur10408
too much of this list is populated by that ethereal indie pop crap that sounds like it's a 3 minute intro with 30 seconds of an actual song. The bands that got that sound and do it right are few and far in between. I've heard the majority of these bands and I couldn't sit through more than 3 or 4 of their songs before my mind drifts off and I totally disregard the music. Not that the music is in the background and my mind drifts, just that my ears stop paying attention because it's so minimalistic and just plain boring.
Start Conversation
January 13, 2012Nameless Poseur10434
Its TRUE - popular indie rock is mind numbingly mellow. The only people kicking up the rock on this list are the gals like Wild Flag and PJ Harvey. Lets pray that women save us from boredom in 2012
Start Conversation
January 13, 2012Nameless Poseur10440
lets hope 2012 is gonna be a much better year in music
Start Conversation
January 13, 2012Nameless Poseur10448
How is Cold War Kids, Mine is Yours not on this list!? ...such a great album
Start Conversation
January 16, 2012Nameless Poseur10471
Strike Hard, Young Diamond by WILDLIFE should be here!!! Amazing record, I can't believe it's not on every list everywhere. Better than most of the stuff here really...
Start Conversation
Login
Keep me logged in
Prove You Are Not a Robot
To remove this step go back and login.

Year In Review Archive

Picks

Summer Fest Guide
Newsletter

Most Popular Stories

  1. NEWS: French Montana Details 'Excuse My French' TracklistFrench Montana Details 'Excuse My French' Tracklist
  2. MUSIC / VIDEO: The Courtneys "Social Anxiety" (video)The Courtneys -
  3. MUSIC / VIDEO: Boards of Canada "Reach for the Dead"Boards of Canada -
  4. See The Top Twenty Most Popular
SCENE 2013
Liferuiner

Article Published In Dec 11 Issue